Premier Section Finals Series
Champion Team – undefeated for season in bold
| Year | Premiers | Score | Runners Up | Score | Margin | Jock Nelson Medal | Coach | Third | Fourth |
| 2022 | St Kevin’s OB | 5.16.46 | Old Brighton | 3.6.24 | 22 | Tom Jok (SKOB) | Anthony Lynch | Collegians | Old Xaverians |
| 2019 | University Blues | 18.8.116 | St Kevin’s OB | 10.16.76 | 40 | Luke Russell (UB) | Heath Jamieson | Old Xaverians | Collegians |
| 2018 | St Kevin’s OB | 12.13.85 | Collegians | 11.14.80 | 5 | Billy Kanakis (SKOB) | Tom Williams & Guy Martyn | Old Trinity | Old Brighton |
| 2017 | St Kevin’s OB | 10.10.70 | Collegians | 9.13.67 | 3 | Mitch Brown (SKOB) | Shannon Grant | University Blues | De La Salle |
| 2016 | Old Xaverians | 9.7.61 | Old Trinity | 7.12.54 | 7 | Caydn Beetham (OX) | Ted Woodruff & Pat Hawkins | University Blues | University Blacks |
| 2015 | St Bernard’s |
17.11.113 | Old Trinity | 15.15.105 | 8 | Mitch Hannan (StB) | Anthony Rock | University Blues | De La Salle |
| 2014 | University Blacks |
13.12.90 | Collegians | 7.4.46 | 44 | Bede Mahon (UB) | Cameron Roberts | St Bernard’s | Old Scotch |
| 2013 | Old Xaverians |
13.17.95 | St Bedes/Mentone Tigers | 6.9.45 | 50 | Chris Waller (OX) | Nick Bourke & Dom Berry | University Blacks | Old Scotch |
| 2012 | Collegians |
10.11.71 | Old Xaverians | 9.10.64 | 7 | Andrew Scott (Col) | Mark Hibbins & Simon Arnott | De La Salle | Old Scotch |
| 2011 | Collegians | 18.20.128 | St Bedes/Mentone Tigers | 14.8.92 | 36 | Stuart Inglis (Col) | Mark Hibbins & Simon Arnott | Old Xaverians | University Blues |
| 2010 | Old Xaverians | 11.8.74 | Collegians | 7.12.54 | 20 | Ryan Colbert (OX) | Simon Lethlean | ||
| 2009 | Old Xaverians |
9.6.60 | De La Salle O.C. | 8.9.57 | 3 | Luke Howard (OX) | Simon Lethlean | ||
| 2008 | St Bedes/Mentone Tigers | 10.17.77 | Collegians | 5.17.47 | 30 | Luke Wintle (SBMT) | Luke Beveridge | ||
| 2007 | Old Xaverians |
18.15.123 | Old Brighton | 10.16.76 | 47 | Nick Serafini (OX) | Barry Richardson | ||
| 2006 | Old Haileyburians | 13.8.86 | Old Xaverians | 9.9.63 | 23 | Carl Steinfort (OH) | Peter Nicholson | ||
| 2005 | Old Xaverians | 13.7.85 | University Blues | 11.10.76 | 9 | Adam N Chatfield (OX) | Barry Richardson | ||
| 2004 | University Blues | 18.13.121 | St Bernard’s O.C. | 7.13.55 | 66 | E.P. Clark (UB) | John Kanis | ||
| 2003 | Old Xaverians | 18.20.128 | St Bernard’s O.C. | 8.17.65 | 63 | Tim Ockleshaw (OX) | Michael Sholly | ||
| 2002 | St Bernard’s O.C. | 20.15.135 | Old Xaverians | 15.14.104 | 31 | Daniel Byrne (StB) | Peter Nicholson | ||
| 2001 | Marcellin | 16.7.103 | St. Kevin’s O.B. | 9.19.73 | 30 | L. D. McMillan (Mar) | Simon Dalrymple | ||
| 2000 | Old Xaverians | 22.14.146 | St. Bernards | 16.5.101 | 45 | Adam S. Jones (OX) | Tim O’Shaughnessy | ||
| 1999 | Old Xaverians | 22.14.146 | Old Melburnians | 13.17.95 | 51 | Matthew B. Bourke (OX) | Tim O’Shaughnessy | ||
| 1998 | Old Xaverians | 21.13.139 | Old Scotch Collegians | 11.12.78 | 61 | Simon A. Wood (OX) | Tim O’Shaughnessy | ||
| 1997 | Old Xaverians | 10.13.73 | Old Scotch Collegians | 9.13.67 | 6 | Michael L. Blood (OX) | Nick Bourke | ||
| 1996 | Old Xaverians | 8.10.58 | Collegians | 8.5.53 | 5 | Michael A. Holmes (OX) | Nick Bourke | ||
| 1995 | Old Xaverians | 15.11.101 | University Blues | 2.5.17 | 84 | Michael L. Blood (OX) | Barry Richardson | ||
| 1994 | Old Melburnians | 11.13.79 | Collegians | 7.19.61 | 18 | Jeremy Nichols (OM) | Roger Ellingworth | ||
| 1993 | Collegians |
11.13.79 | De La Salle O.C. | 6.13.49 | 30 | Mark G. Hibbins (Col) | Lee Carlson | ||
| 1992 | Collegians |
14.23.107 | De La Salle O.C. | 9.13.67 | 40 | Lee Carlson | |||
| 1991 | De La Salle O.C. |
12.10.82 | North Old Boys | 11.11.77 | 5 | Bernard Dunn | |||
| 1990 | Ormond | 14.12.96 | Collegians | 12.17.89 | 7 | Mike McArthur-Allen | |||
| 1989 | Ormond |
17.11.113 | Collegians | 9.11.65 | 48 | Mike McArthur-Allen | |||
| 1988 | Ormond |
14.11.95 | Old Xaverians | 8.11.59 | 36 | Mike McArthur-Allen | |||
| 1987 | Ormond | 15.11.101 | Old Xaverians | 12.12.84 | 17 | Mike McArthur-Allen | |||
| 1986 | Collegians |
21.6.132 | North Old Boys | 11.15.81 | 51 | Bruce Fergusson | |||
| 1985 | Ormond | 16.14.110 | De La Salle O.C. | 14.11.95 | 15 | Mike McArthur-Allen | |||
| 1984 | De La Salle O.C. |
13.14.92 | Ormond | 6.19.55 | 37 | John Pollard | |||
| 1983 | De La Salle O.C. | 11.7.73 | University Blues | 7.10.52 | 21 | Neil LeLievre | |||
| 1982 | North Old Boys | 19.7.121 | De La Salle O.C. | 8.15.63 | 58 | Terry Scanlon | |||
| 1981 | Old Xaverians | 15.22.112 | North Old Boys | 13.15.91 | 21 | Michael Green | |||
| 1980 | De La Salle O.C. | 11.14.80 | University Blues | 7.18.60 | 20 | Gavin White | |||
| 1979 | De La Salle O.C. | 17.15.117 | University Blues | 12.10.82 | 35 | Bernie Sheehy | |||
| 1978 | Old Scotch Collegians | 16.16.112 | North Old Boys | 16.11.107 | 5 | Laurie Aghan | |||
| 1977 | De La Salle O.C. | 9.20.74 | North Old Boys | 11.5.71 | 3 | Bernie Sheehy | |||
| 1976 | North Old Boys | 18.18.126 | St Bernard’s O.C. | 11.11.77 | 49 | Shane Maguire | |||
| 1975 | St Bernard’s O.C. | 19.13.127 | North Old Boys | 12.10.82 | 45 | Gerard Mitchell | |||
| 1974 | University Blacks | 12.10.82 | Ormond | 9.14.68 | 14 | Peter O’Donohue | |||
| 1973 | Ormond | 12.13.85 | St Bernard’s O.C. | 8.7.55 | 30 | Ted Farrell | |||
| 1972 | Ormond | 9.13.67 | Old Paradians | 8.13.61 | 6 | Ted Farrell | |||
| 1971 | Ormond | 8.14.52 | University Blues | 4.16.40 | 12 | Ted Farrell | |||
| 1970 | Caulfield Gr. | 14.18.102 | Coburg | 15.10.100 | 2 | John Wilson | |||
| 1969 | Coburg | 13.17.95 | Ormond | 12.12.84 | 11 | Alan Salter | |||
| 1968 | Old Paradians | 17.23.125 | Caulfield Gr. | 7.8.50 | 75 | John Booth | |||
| 1967 | Old Paradians | 16.15.111 | Caulfield Gr. | 13.15.93 | 18 | John Booth | |||
| 1966 | Old Paradians | 12.9.81 | M.H.S.O.B. | 11.6.72 | 9 | John Booth | |||
| 1965 | University Blacks | 17.12.114 | Coburg | 10.5.65 | 49 | Frank Dunin | |||
| 1964 | Old Paradians | 10.11.71 | Old Xaverians | 9.13.67 | 4 | Maurie Considine | |||
| 1963 | Old Paradians | 10.13.73 | Ormond | 8.9.57 | 16 | Maurie Considine | |||
| 1962 | Old Paradians | 16.14.110 | M.H.S.O.B. | 9.9.63 | 47 | Maurie Considine | |||
| 1961 | Collegians | 17.9.111 | Old Melburnians | 9.13.67 | 44 | Geoff W Hibbins | |||
| 1960 | University Blues | 9.10.64 | Old Melburnians | 6.6.42 | 22 | Andy Brannan | |||
| 1959 | Collegians | 14.12.96 | Old Scotch Collegians | 11.8.74 | 22 | Max J Rush | |||
| 1958 | Collegians | 9.6.60 | Old Scotch Collegians | 8.6.54 | 6 | Geoff W Hibbins | |||
| 1957 | Collegians | 13.12.90 | University Blues | 2.12.24 | 66 | Geoff W Hibbins | |||
| 1956 | Ivanhoe | 6.14.50 | Coburg | 5.12.42 | 8 | Harold Winberg | |||
| 1955 | Old Melburnians | 11.18.84 | Ormond | 6.12.48 | 36 | Murray Mitchell | |||
| 1954 | Old Melburnians | 9.19.73 | University Blues | 9.14.68 | 5 | Peter Cox | |||
| 1953 | Old Melburnians | 12.16.88 | University Blues | 6.8.44 | 44 | John Mitchell | |||
| 1952 | University Blues | 20.1.121 | Ormond | 8.16.64 | 57 | Geoff Sinclair | |||
| 1951 | Hampton Rovers | 7.12.54 | Ormond | 7.7.49 | 5 | Norm Jones | |||
| 1950 | Ormond | 9.12.66 | University Blacks | 9.8.62 | 4 | Lou Bols | |||
| 1949 | University Blacks | 14.24.108 | Ormond | 6.12.48 | 60 | Keith Fleming | |||
| 1948 | University Blacks | 15.11.101 | Old Melburnians | 7.14.56 | 45 | Keith Fleming | |||
| 1947 | University Blacks | 17.20.122 | Ormond | 17.11.113 | 9 | Lee Atkinson | |||
| 1946 | University Blacks | 22.19.151 | Old Scotch Collegians | 13.16.94 | 57 | Lee Atkinson | |||
| 1939 | University Blacks | 15.18.108 | Ormond | 10.8.68 | 40 | Ray Brew | |||
| 1938 | University Blacks | 17.19.121 | State Sav. Bank | 15.10.100 | 21 | Ray Brew | |||
| 1937 | Collegians | 15.17.107 | Ormond | 8.20.68 | 39 | Clarrie H Von Tom | |||
| 1936 | Collegians | 14.18.102 | State Sav. Bank | 6.11.47 | 55 | Perc Wilson | |||
| 1935 | University Blacks | 16.12.108 | Old Scotch Collegians | 12.20.92 | 16 | Stuart King | |||
| 1934 | Old Scotch Collegians | 16.1.97 | University Blacks | 13.11.89 | 8 | Vic Belcher | |||
| 1933 | Old Scotch Collegians | 15.16.106 | University Blacks | 10.14.74 | 32 | Gus Dobrigh | |||
| 1932 | Old Scotch Collegians | 13.18.96 | State Sav. Bank | 10.8.68 | 28 | Lou Bols | |||
| 1931 | Old Scotch Collegians | 10.11.71 | Elsternwick | 7.13.55 | 16 | Jack Petchell | |||
| 1930 | Old Melburnians | 23.16.154 | Elsternwick | 7.9.51 | 103 | Jack Cordner | |||
| 1929 | University Blacks | 9.10.64 | Old Melburnians | 5.6.36 | 28 | ||||
| 1928 | University Blacks | 15.18.108 | Old Melburnians | 7.6.48 | 60 | Pat Sheehan | |||
| 1927 | Old Scotch Collegians | 19.1.115 | University B | 13.12.90 | 25 | Clive Fergie | |||
| 1926 | Old Scotch Collegians | 9.16.70 | Elsternwick | 7.16.58 | 12 | Clive Fergie | |||
| 1925 | Elsternwick | 6.15.51 | Old Scotch Collegians | 3.12.30 | 21 | ||||
| 1924 | Old Scotch Collegians | 11.6.72 | Hampton | 7.13.55 | 17 | Clive “Cocky” Heatley | |||
| 1923 | Old Scotch Collegians | 17.11.113 | University B | 12.7.79 | 34 | Clive “Cocky” Heatley | |||
| 1922 | University B | 10.11.71 | Collegians | 7.15.57 | 14 | ||||
| 1921 | University B | 9.13.67 | University A | 9.8.62 | 5 | ||||
| 1920 | Elsternwick | 11.1.67 | Collegians | 5.6.36 | 31 | ||||
| 1915 | Collingwood District | 9.1.55 | Leopold | 6.13.49 | 6 | ||||
| 1914 | South Yarra | Collingwood District | |||||||
| 1913 | Leopold | 6.14.50 | Collingwood District | 3.11.29 | 21 | ||||
| 1912 | Beverley | South Yarra | |||||||
| 1911 | Leopold | Collegians | |||||||
| 1910 | Leopold | Carlton District | |||||||
| 1909 | South Yarra | Beverley | |||||||
| 1908 | South Yarra | Leopold | |||||||
| 1907 | University | Brighton | |||||||
| 1906 | University | Collegians | |||||||
| 1905 | Port Rovers | South Yarra | |||||||
| 1904 | Collegians | Port Rovers | Harold J Stewart | ||||||
| 1903 | Brighton | Leopold | |||||||
| 1902 | Collegians | Brighton | Harold J Stewart | ||||||
| 1901 | Leopold | Collegians | |||||||
| 1900 | Leopold | 7.1.43 | South Melbourne Juniors | 2.8.20 | 23 | ||||
| 1899 | Collegians | Leopold | Harold J Stewart | ||||||
| 1898 | Collegians | Caulfield | Harold J Stewart | ||||||
| 1897 | South St. Kilda | Collegians | |||||||
| 1896 | Collegians | Caulfield | Harold J Stewart | ||||||
| 1895 | South St. Kilda | St. Mary’s | |||||||
| 1894 | South St. Kilda | Collegians | |||||||
| 1893 | South St. Kilda | Alberton | |||||||
| 1892 | Collegians | Alberton |