See the winners of each men’s reserve competition in each section.
The Reserve Section premiership cups are as follows:
Premier: N.C. Rundle (1985)
Premier B: J.F.X. Dillon (1985)
Premier C: A.J. Keam (1985)
| Year | Premier | Premier B | Premier C | Division 1 | Division 2 | Division 3 | Division 4 |
| 2024 | Old Xaverians | Old Trinity | Parkdale Vultures | West Brunswick | Brunswick | Richmond Central | |
| 2023 | Old Xaverians | St Bernards | Old Ivanhoe | Kew FC | Parkside | Elsternwick | North Brunswick |
| 2022 | Old Xaverians | De La Salle | Old Geelong | PEGS | Brunswick | South Melbourne | Albert Park |
| 2019 | Old Xaverians | Old Scotch | Williamstown CYMS | Kew FC | Whitefriars | Emmaus St Leo’s | South Melbourne Districts |
| 2018 | Old Melburnians | Beaumaris | Fitzroy | Ormond | Whitefriars | Hawthorn AFC | North Brunswick |
| 2017 | Old Xaverians | Old Brighton | Caulfield Gr. | Ormond | Prahran Assumption | UHS-VU | Aquinas |
| 2016 | University Blues | Beaumaris | Williamstown CYMS | St Mary’s Salesian | MHSOB | Swinburne University | Westbourne Grammarians |
| 2015 | Old Xaverians | Old Melburnians | PEGS | Ormond | Ivanhoe | West Brunswick | Canterbury |
| 2014 | University Blacks | University Blues | Parkdale Vultures | Prahran Assumption | St Mary’s Salesian | Richmond Central | Hawthorn |
| 2013 | Old Xaverians | Old Melburnians | Marcellin O.C. | Old Geelong | Therry Penola | Kew | Eley Park |
| 2012 | De La Salle O.C. | University Blacks | Fitzroy | Old Geelong | Bulleen-Templestowe | Yarra Valley | Swinburne University |
| 2011 | De La Salle O.C. | Old Brighton Gr. | AJAX | Banyule | Therry Penola | UHS-VU | South Mornington |
| 2010 | Uni Blues | University Blacks | Caulfield Grammarians | NOB/St Pats | Banyule | UHS-VU | Monash Gryphons |
| 2009 | Uni Blues | Old Melburnians | Mazenod | NOB/St Pats | Williamstown CYMS | Bentleigh | La Trobe Uni |
| 2008 | Uni Blues | Old Essendon | Ormond | NOB/St Pats | Werribee | Williamstown CYMS | Kew |
| 2007 | Old Xaverians | St Kevins | Ormond | Old Geelong | Werribee | Swinburne Uni | Eltham |
| 2006 | Old Xaverians | University Blacks | St Bedes Mentone Tigers | Old Mentonians | La Trobe University | Kew | Powerhouse |
| 2005 | Old Scotch Collegians | De La Salle O.C. | Beaumaris | Fitzroy Reds | Old Geelong^ | St Johns | Eltham |
| 2004 | University Blues | St Kevins | Hampton Rovers | University Blacks | La Trobe University | Rupertswood | Old Westbourne |
| 2003 | St Bernards | Old Brighton Gr. | Collegians | A.J.A.X. | Peninsula O.B.^ | Werribee Amateurs | North Brunswick |
| 2002 | Old Xaverians | Old Paradians | Caulfield Grammarians | Monash Blues | Yarra Valley | St Johns | Albert Park |
| 2001 | Old Xaverians | Old Haileybury | Collegians | Old Camberwell | Parkside | South Melb. Districts | Syndal Tally Ho |
| 2000 | Old Xaverians | Old Brighton Gr. | Therry Penola | Caulfield Gr. | University Blacks | Williamstown CYMS | St. Marys |
| 1999 | University Blues | Old Brighton Gr. | Therry Penola | A.J.A.X. | Geographic split 1995-1999. See table below. | Eltham |
| 1998 | Old Xaverians | Ormond | St. Bedes Mentone Tigers | A.J.A.X. | West Brunswick |
| 1997 | Old Xaverians | Old Brighton Gr. | St. Bedes Mentone Tigers | Old Geelong | |
| 1996 | University Blues | Old Brighton Gr. | Marcellin O.C. | Monash Blues | |
| 1995 | Old Xaverians | Old Paradians | Monash Blues | University Blacks | |
| 1994 | North Old Boys | University Blues | M.H.S.O.B. | University Blacks | Aquinas O.C. | Oakleigh | University Reds |
| 1993 | Old Scotch Collegians | Old Melburnians | M.H.S.O.B. | University Blacks | Old Camberwell Gr. | La Trobe University | Balwyn Combined |
| 1992 | Collegians | Old Brighton Gr. | University Blacks | Mazenod O.C. | Glenhuntly* | St. Patrick’s Mentone | |
| 1991 | De La Salle O.C. | Old Paradians | St. Kilda C.B.O.C. | M.H.S.O.B. | Mazenod O.C. | U.H.S.O.B. | |
| 1990 | De La Salle O.C. | Bulleen-Templestowe | Thomastown | M.H.S.O.B. | Old Geelong | U.H.S.O.B. | |
| 1989 | Ormond | De La Salle O.C. | Old Haileyburians | Whitefriars O.C. | West Brunswick | Mazenod O.C. | |
| 1988 | Ormond | Kew | Banyule | State Bank | Old Geelong | Doveton S.J.O.C. | |
| 1987 | De La Salle O.C. | Ivanhoe | Kew | Preston M.B.O.B. | Old Essendon Gr. | Whitefriars O.C. | |
| 1986 | Ormond | Old Paradians | Banyule | Preston M.B.O.B. | Brunswick | Old Essendon Gr. | |
| 1985 | Ormond | Old Paradians | Therry C.C.O.B. | Old Mentonians | Preston M.B.O.B. | U.H.S.O.B. | |
| 1984 | Ormond | University Blacks | Hampton Rovers | Therry C.C.O.B. | U.H.S.O.B. | Preston M.B.O.B. | |
| 1983 | North Old Boys | St. Bernard’s O.C. | St. Kilda C.B.O.C. | Therry C.C.O.B. | Thomastown | La Trobe University | |
| 1982 | Ormond | Bulleen-Templestowe | Coburg | St. Bedes O.C. | Thomastown | Brunswick | |
| 1981 | De La Salle O.C. | Collegians | Bulleen-Templestowe | Coburg | Old Mentonians | Banyule | |
| 1980 | De La Salle O.C. | Old Scotch Collegians | Geelong | St. Bedes O.C. | North Brunswick | Therry C.C.O.B. | |
| 1979 | Ormond | Parkside | Hampton Rovers | Bulleen-Templestowe | North Brunswick | St. Pius | |
| 1978 | Ormond | Monash Blues | Old Brighton Gr. | Power House | St. Bedes O.C. | Bulleen United | |
| 1977 | North Old Boys | Ivanhoe | Parkside | State Bank | Heatherton | St. Bedes O.C. | |
| 1976 | Coburg | Ivanhoe | Fawkner | Old Brighton Gr. | St. Kevin’s O.B. | St. Bedes O.C. | |
| 1975 | St. Bernard’s O.C. | Ivanhoe | Parkside | Fawkner | Elsternwick | Heatherton | |
| 1974 | Reservoir O.B. | Monash Blues | St. Kilda C.B.O.C. | Hampton Rovers | A.N.Z. Bank | Old Mentonians | |
| 1973 | Ormond | Old Scotch Collegians | Old Haileyburians | Hampton Rovers | Old Ivanhoe Gr. | Fawkner | |
| 1972 | Monash Blues | University Blacks | Reservoir O.B. | Parkside | Old Ivanhoe Gr. | Monash Whites | |
| 1971 | St. Bernard’s O.C. | University Blacks | St. Kilda C.B.O.C. | Parkside | A.J.A.X. | Old Mentonians | |
| 1970 | Ormond | University Blacks | Old Carey Gr. | St. Kevin’s O.B. | Elsternwick | | |
| 1969 | University Blacks | Old Scotch Collegians | Hampton Rovers | Old Trinity Gr. | A.N.Z. Bank | | |
| 1968 | Old Paradians | Ormond | Hampton Rovers | Old Haileyburians | Old Trinity Gr. | | |
| 1967 | Old Scotch Collegians | Ormond | Monash University | Hampton Rovers | Old Trinity Gr. | | |
| 1966 | Old Xaverians | Ormond | North Melbourne C.B.C.O.B. | Old Geelong Gr. | Glenhuntly | | |
| 1965 | University Blacks | Ormond | Hampton Rovers | North Melbourne C.B.C.O.B. | ES & A | | |
E Sections 1995-1999
| Year | Section | Division 2 (E Section) |
| 1999 | Blue | St. Johns O.C. |
| 1999 | White | University Blacks |
| 1998 | Blue | Old Camberwell Gr. |
| 1998 | White | Kew |
| 1997 | East | Old Carey |
| 1997 | Central | University Blacks |
| 1997 | South | Southbank (CBA) |
| 1996 | East | Aquinas O.C. |
| 1996 | Central | University Blacks |
| 1996 | South | Peninsula O.B. |
| 1995 | East | St. Leo’s Wattle Park |
| 1995 | Central | Old Essendon |
| 1995 | South | Salesian O.C. |
Reserve Sections 1960-64
| Season | Section | Winner |
| 1964 | RES 1 | Old Xaverians |
| 1964 | RES 2 | Old Scotch Collegians |
| 1964 | RES 3 | Foots TCOB |
| 1964 | RES 4 | NMCBCOB |
| 1963 | RES 1 | Old Paradians |
| 1963 | RES 2 | Kew |
| 1963 | RES 3 | UHSOB |
| 1963 | RES 4 | St Bernard’s |
| 1962 | RES SW | De La Salle O.C. |
| 1962 | RES SE | Ormond |
| 1962 | RES NW | Ivanhoe |
| 1961 | RESERVES N | Old Scotch Collegians |
| 1961 | RESERVES S | Ormond |
| 1961 | RES CHAMP | Old Scotch Collegians |
| 1960 | RESERVES | Old Melburnians |
