Scotch Stars go back-to-back

Old Scotch have claimed the 2025 VAFA William Buck Premier Women’s premiership in a thrilling five-point win over Caulfield Grammarians, 4.9 (33) to 4.4 (28), at the end of an intense contest that tested the nerves of players, coaches, and supporters alike.

The 2024 premiers had a testing 2025 season but achieved the rare feat of back-to-back Women’s premierships.

Caulfield started the stronger of the two sides, taking a seven-point lead into quarter time with Isla Mottram and Olivia Rundle instrumental in the Field’s gaining ascendancy. By half time, however, the Cardinals had worked their way into the game, lifting their clearance work and forward efficiency to edge ahead 3.2 (20) to 2.4 (16).

The third quarter proved pivotal. The 2024 premiers dominated territory and added 1.6 while holding Caulfield scoreless, establishing what looked like a match-winning 16-point lead at the final change.

However, the Fields weren’t finished, with the wind at their backs and renewed intensity, they surged forward repeatedly in the last quarter, cutting the margin to just five points. Despite relentless pressure, Old Scotch’s defence held firm across the final 10 minutes to secure the premiership.

For Old Scotch, Jordan Mifsud was once again outstanding on the big stage, booting two goals and earning best-on-ground honours for the second consecutive grand final. She was well supported by Katie Hunter-Scott and Emily Tassiopoulos, while Mia Cowan and Lucy Murphy added vital goals.

Caulfield’s fight was led by Isla Mottram, Olivia Rundle and Chloe O’Malley, with O’Malley, Ebony Angelopoulos, Nat Barbara and Marguerite Purcell each contributing majors.

Caulfield Grammarians coach Danielle Di Stefano praised her team’s growth across the season.

“Obviously we are disappointed with the loss but really pleased with our season overall. Our goal was to compete with and beat some of the best and I think we were able to do that.

Our strong start and pressure were pleasing, but ultimately our inability to capitalise on inside 50s let us down. While the loss hurts, I know this has made the group even hungrier for ultimate success.”

Old Scotch coach Dean Anderson reflected on his side’s resilience in the face of a late Caulfield surge.

“The game was tight, testing everyone’s nerve and capacity to hang in there. Clearances and effective use post-clearance were important, and we managed to get on top in the critical third quarter.

“Our inaccuracy in front of goal kept Caulfield in the game, and their determined last quarter almost got them over the line. Our stars held a five-point lead for almost 10 minutes, and the brave efforts to thwart repeat entries will be a lasting memory from what was an intense game.”

“Our inaccuracy in front of goal kept Caulfield in the game, and their determined last quarter almost got them over the line.”

Anderson was also full of praise for Mifsud and her performance on the big stage.

“Jordan thoroughly deserved all accolades for her second best-on-ground grand final in a row.”

In the end, Old Scotch’s composure under pressure delivered premiership glory, while Caulfield Grammarians walked away with enormous respect and plenty of belief for the future.